As hard as we try as stepmothers to avoid having an argument
with our husband’s ex-wife, it’s just inevitable that at some time or another,
it’s going to happen. I’ll be
honest: Lucy and I are anything but close. We’re polite and cordial to one another, but considering she
lives in Montreal and I live in Wichita and I rarely have the occasion to see
her, that’s been the extent of our interaction for the last seven years. Lucy would occasionally call our house
to talk to Aidan when the kids weren’t here to discuss finances or the kids’
behavior. The majority of the
time, she would only call his cell phone when he was at work. I just assumed that she wanted to talk
to Aidan when the kids weren’t home so that she could have some privacy for the
call on her end. She never called
our house with great frequency when the kids weren’t here, but she did make the
occasional phone call. When the
kids were visiting, though, Lucy regularly called our home – not on Aidan’s
cell phone. This all changed after
the kids’ visit during last summer of 2008.
At one point during their visit last summer, Lucy called the
house around 10:30 pm, which was way past the boys’ bedtime. On this particular day, the boys had
been rather cranky and getting them into bed had been difficult. I was in bed when the phone rang and I
quickly grabbed it, hoping that it wouldn’t wake up the kids.
“Hello, Kath-er-ine. It’s Lucy. Connor called me earlier today and I’m returning his phone
call,” she said.
“Hi Lucy. I’d
be happy to put Connor on the phone with you, but he’s actually in bed right
now. Can I have him call you
tomorrow?” I asked.
“Actually, I’d really like to talk with him now, if you
don’t mind,” she answered.
I didn’t know it at the time, but this was a pivotal moment
in our relationship as biological mother and stepmother. I had just committed a cardinal sin of
being a stepmother: I was preventing the biological mother from speaking with
her child. The only problem was
that I didn’t know it.
“Lucy, the boys have been pretty ratty today, and if I go in
to wake up Connor, then Rory will get woken up too. Now, I’m happy to have him call you tomorrow and you guys
can talk for as long as you’d like, but it’s just really late here.”
“Kath-er-ine, I’d
like to speak with him right now,”
she said.
“Alright, I’ll go and get him.” I shot Aidan, who had been preparing his clothes for work
the next day, a look of pure disgust and stomped off to the boys’ room. Very quietly, I shook Connor awake and
whispered to him to come with me.
Groggily, he climbed out of bed and followed me to our bedroom.
“Why did you wake me up, Katie?” he asked.
“Your mom’s on the phone and she would like to speak with
you. She said that she’s returning
your phone call from earlier,” I said.
I didn’t listen to the phone conversation – I always make a
point of giving the kids privacy when they speak with their mother – and so I
went into my bathroom and sat there, waiting for the call to be over. Meanwhile, Aidan lay in bed and
read. About five minutes passed
and Connor got off the phone. I
walked out of the bathroom and climbed into bed.
“So, is everything OK with your mom?” I asked.
Connor nodded sleepily. “Katie? Can I
please go back to bed now?”
“Of course, sweetie.
You know, you can call your mom back tomorrow and talk for as long as
you’d like, OK?”
He nodded again and walked back to bed.
I looked over at Aidan with a disgusted look on my
face. “Now you tell me,” I said to
him. “Was that really necessary?”
“No,” Aidan answered.
“But you also had a definite nasty tone of voice going on there.”
“What kind of tone of voice? One like I was irritated that I had to wake Connor up at
10:30 at night?”
“Yeah, kind of like that. I can tell you that Lucy won’t be happy about this,” Aidan
said.
“Who cares? She
should know better! And for that
matter, whose side are you on, anyway?
Don’t you think it was ridiculous for her to call so late, and then she only wanted to talk to Connor?” I asked, becoming very
angry.
“Quit acting like a child!” Aidan snapped. “Of course I think that tonight’s call
was ridiculous, but you’re making it worse.”
“No,” I replied.
“You’re making it worse by standing up for her! Could you please call her tomorrow and
remind her about the boys’ bedtimes?”
“Just drop it, Katie, OK?” Irritated and frustrated with Aidan, I grabbed the blanket
and snapped off my light. I was
done.
A couple of weeks passed, and Lucy called from time to
time. If I happened to answer the
phone, she was cordial toward me.
However, the late-night phone call was never mentioned. Stupidly, I assumed that I’d never hear
about it again – but that was not to be.
Only a day went by once the boys were home in Montreal before Aidan
started getting phone calls from Lucy complaining about my attempt to thwart
her from speaking with her child.
Little did I know that by trying to let Connor sleep, I had crossed a
line with Lucy: I had prevented her access to her child, and Lucy had spent the
last few weeks stewing over this infraction.
As a side note, I always know when Lucy calls Aidan at work
because when he comes home, he is irritated in a certain way – a way that comes
across as something chewing at him from the inside that just won’t go
away. He usually will tell me what
has transpired, but for some reason, this time he didn’t. But when Aidan came home like this for
three days in a row, I finally confronted him and asked him what had happened
with Lucy.
“What makes you think that something’s going on with Lucy?”
Aidan asked.
“Because I can tell when she’s been calling you at work and
you guys have been fighting, that’s why.
This has been going on for days, so why don’t you just sit down and tell
me what’s wrong,” I said. Aidan
slowly walked across the room and sank down into a chair.
“Lucy’s mad because of that night she called to talk to
Connor and you didn’t let her,” he said.
“Wait a second,” I said, starting to feel that
far-too-familiar feeling that I was going to lose my temper. “Are you talking about that night that
she called at 10:30, and after I tried
to explain that Connor was asleep,
I woke him up because she insisted? How exactly is that me not letting her
talk to her son?”
“Just stop – OK?
Stop it! I’m sick of this
shit!” Aidan responded.
“Well, just answer me one thing: what did you tell her?” I
asked.
“I told her that she needed to get over it.”
“Then why have you continued to take her phone calls when
she’s apparently been very pissed off at me for the last few days? Why didn’t you tell her to stop with
her crap days ago?” I yelled.
“This is exactly why I didn’t want to tell you!” Aidan
yelled back at me. “The last thing
I need is to have you and her yelling at
me!”
“Fine!” I snapped.
“But don’t you think you could have suggested to her that she call me
and take up her problem with me personally instead of going through you? Doesn’t that seem like the mature and
adult way of handling this situation?”
“Just drop it already!
I’m sick of listening to the two of you bitch!” Aidan yelled.
“Oh, I’ll drop it.
But I’m going to put an end to this right now,” I said. I took a deep breath and calmed
down. “I’m going to call her and
apologize and put an end to this thing.”
“Whatever,” Aidan said. And with that, I went upstairs to our room where I’d be
undisturbed. I waited and made
sure that I was calm. I thought
through what I was going to say and the tone of voice I was going to use. OK,
I thought. I’m ready. So I
dialed Lucy’s number and waited, hoping that I wouldn’t get the machine.
“Hello?” Lucy said.
“Hi Lucy, it’s Katie calling.”
“Oh, hello, Katie,” she said. I could tell from her voice that I had definitely caught her
off-guard. I’ve definitely got
the upper-hand, so I’m going to
stay calm, cool, and collected, I thought.
“Lucy, the reason why I’m calling is because Aidan told me
that you’ve been calling him the last few days because you’ve been upset with
something I did,” I said.
“Well, I, uh” she hesitated.
“Lucy, I’m calling to apologize. When you called that night, I in no way wanted to prevent
you from speaking with Connor. In
fact, nothing could have been further from my mind. The kids were sleeping and it was late. I just thought that if you knew that,
you wouldn’t want to talk to Connor until the next day. I had no idea it was that important to
you to speak to him. I promise, it
will never happen again,” I said.
“Well, thank you Kath-er-ine,”
she said.
“Lucy, please call me Katie,” I said. Christ, I thought. Here
we go with the Katherine crap. By now I’d figured out that she only
called me Katherine when she was feeling insecure or wanted to talk down to me
like I was a naughty child. But I
kept going with what I had planned to say.
“I also wanted to let you know that if I ever do something
in the future that upsets you, could you please just let me know and give me
the opportunity to apologize and so that we could work things out
together? We really don’t need to
put Aidan in the middle, OK?” I asked.
“Fine, Katherine.
There actually is something that
I’d like to talk to you about,” she said.
“Great! What is
it?” I asked.
“Well, Aidan is really doing a very bad job about telling
Rory that he’ll never live with you two.”
“I beg your pardon?” I asked.
“You must understand, I blame Aidan for this, but you can
help. Every time Rory asks if he
can live with you, I want you to tell him ‘no,’ alright?”
“Lucy,” I said, taking a deep breath knowing that she wasn’t
going to like my answer. “I can’t
do that.”
“Well, I don’t see why not,” she said and I could her voice
becoming edgy.
“Lucy, I can’t do that because first of all, it’s none of my
business. Sure, I get a say in who
lives in my house, but where Rory lives is a decision that should be made
between you, Aidan, and Rory. I
would just encourage you to think about what is in Rory’s best interests,” I
said.
“I see,” she said coldly. “You know what Kath-er-ine? I’ve put up with a lot from you over
these last years.” Uh-oh, I thought.
This is not going to go well. “You put ideas into my children’s heads
that I don’t approve of, you don’t understand that a child’s place is with his
mother, and you ruined my marriage.”
“Lucy, wait a second.
I had absolutely nothing to do with your divorce. I also think that we’re getting off the
subject: I called to apologize to you,” I said.
“And Aidan has been a terrible father by moving so far away
from his children,” she continued, as though she hadn’t heard a word I said.
“Lucy, once again: I called to apologize,” I knew that under
no circumstances was I going to engage in this conversation, so the best thing
I could do is just repeat myself by going back to the original reason why I had
called her: be the broken record.
This was the best technique I had learned to use when dealing with
irrational people.
“If Aidan wanted to be any kind of a father, he never would
have left his children in the first place. And now, Aidan has allowed Rory to think that he has a
chance that he can possibly even live with you,” she continued.
“OK, Lucy,” I said.
I wasn’t going to listen to any more of this garbage – not to mention
that our so-called conversation was going absolutely nowhere. “I will not tolerate anyone putting
Aidan down for any reason whatsoever.
Once again, I’m going to suggest that both you and Aidan need to think
about what’s in Rory’s best interests.
And for the last time, I simply called to apologize to you. So, if that’s it for now, I hope that
you have a good evening,” I said.
“Fine then.
Good-bye,” she said and hung up the phone.
I was shaking after that encounter. In my mind, I had handled myself well
and not lowered myself to her level.
I had not taken her bait about her divorce, Rory wanting to live with
us, or anything else. I also made
it clear to her that I would not listen to any of her insults towards
Aidan. But that line that I was
responsible for breaking up her marriage?
Who was she kidding? I
didn’t even start dating Aidan until after they were separated! My God! She’s just looking for any reason she can to hate me. To be
perfectly honest, I was pretty proud of the way I handled myself.
I tried to shake off the confrontation and went back
downstairs to tell Aidan what had happened. He looked genuinely shocked when I told him that I had
called and apologized to Lucy – I guess he didn’t think that I’d actually do
it. I also told him about what
Lucy said after I apologized.
For whatever reason, Aidan didn’t seem that surprised. We didn’t talk about it any more that
evening, and I thought that after my apology, Lucy’s angry phone calls to Aidan
would stop. I was wrong.
The next night, Aidan came home from work, and he was
furious with me. “Katie, what
exactly did you say to Lucy yesterday?” he shouted.
“I told you everything. I also had to go into the broken record routine because she
was bad-mouthing you and accusing me of ruining your marriage. I wasn’t going to let her go on with
her lies, so I kept bringing it back to the fact that I’d called to apologize
to her,” I said.
“Well, today Lucy called me again – and she was pissed. She said that you kept repeating
yourself over and over last night, and that you’re too self-assured and too
self-confident. Why did you have
to do that?”
“You can’t be serious!” I yelled at him. “I wasn’t going to sit there and be
insulted or let her insult you!
You know how I am when I’m dealing with someone who’s behaving
irrationally – I repeat what the conversation was supposed to be about and try
to get things back on track! Are
you actually taking Lucy’s side on this?
Since when is it wrong to apologize and stand up for myself?” I was so angry with him. My hands were clenched into fists.
“I don’t care what happens between the two of you – I’m out
of it!” Aidan snapped. “And I told
Lucy that too – I’m sick of you two bitching about each other to me!”
“But what you’re missing here is that I was standing up
for you! I won’t let some small-minded and insecure jerk put you or
me down, and if you don’t know that about me after being together for six
years, then I don’t know what your problem is!” I yelled. What was happening here? Why was Aidan mad at me? Was it just the frustration of having
to deal with Lucy’s crap and I was an easy target to take his frustrations out
on? Why couldn’t he see that I had
tried to put an end to the arguing?
As the months passed, Aidan started realizing that I had
only done what I thought was right, and, unfortunately in Lucy’s mind, the only
thing that was “right” would be for me to do whatever she said. Finally, Aidan understands that I will
never allow myself to be controlled by anyone – especially not Lucy, even if it
causes more friction in our relationship.
But the result of my attempted apology has had a long
lasting a consequence: Lucy will not call our home unless the boys are visiting
here. It doesn’t matter if it’s
nine o’clock at night – Lucy will only call Aidan’s cell phone. We’re still pleasant with one another
when we speak, but I think we both know why this is the only interaction that
we have. When I asked Aidan about
the cell phone calls, he told me that basically, Lucy doesn’t want to hear my
voice.
The boys have figured out their mother’s routine of only
calling Aidan’s cell phone except when they are with us, and trust me, they are
full of questions and observations over the whole scenario. But that’s another story.